JAKARTA – Indonesia, the world's largest thermal coal exporter, must bear the market consequences of its repeated export policy changes. Coal buyers from China have firmly rejected Indonesian exporters' proposal to include a shipment waiver clause in new supply contracts, leaving negotiations for 2027 supply contracts at an impasse. This confrontation shows that in a buyer-dominated market structure, China's bargaining power as the largest buyer of Indonesian coal has now translated into real leverage over contract clause content.
A number of Indonesian coal exporters are seeking to include a clause in 2027 supply contracts that would exempt them from the obligation to ship the agreed volume if the Indonesian government cuts production quotas, restricts exports, or delays export approvals. The proposal emerged after the Indonesian government, through the RKAB (Work Plan and Budget) system, adjusted coal production quotas several times this year, compounded by a strong El Niño phenomenon that lowered river water levels in Kalimantan, disrupting barge transportation and materially affecting export shipments.
The rejection stance of Chinese buyers is quite clear: they do not accept Indonesian policy risk being shifted unilaterally to buyers. According to sources familiar with the negotiations, Chinese buyers are particularly reluctant to accept a contract that legally allows suppliers to "not ship" after experiencing shipment disruptions caused by shifting policies this year. This stance immediately stalled negotiations, and some Chinese traders postponed annual contract talks while waiting for clarity on 2027 production targets and quota allocations for each mine from the Indonesian government.
The reason China is able to take a hard line in these negotiations stems from its structural advantage as a big buyer. Data shows that in January–September 2026, China's total coal imports grew about 2.2% year-on-year, but imports from Indonesia actually fell about 5.5%. In the same period, imports from Australia rose 4.9% and imports from Mongolia surged about 40%. This means Indonesia is not an irreplaceable source of supply. Senior analyst at Energy Shift Institute, Idham Fachri, assesses that if supply uncertainty continues, "in the long run it will erode the perception of Indonesia as a reliable supplier and push buyers to seek alternative sources."
In terms of totals, Chinese buyers' confidence is also supported by stock buffers and domestic supply expectations. Jenny Huang, Senior Director at Fitch Ratings, said Chinese buyers are in no rush to aggressively restock at current high price levels because stocks are relatively sufficient and the market expects domestic supply to improve. China's coal imports in October fell 5.52% year-on-year, continuing the 5.7% decline in September. Weakening import demand at the margin further reduces Indonesian exporters' bargaining power.
Indonesia itself is not blind to this risk. Executive Director of the Indonesian Coal Mining Association (APBI), Gita Mahyarani, called the waiver clause a "risk management practice," but acknowledged that its inclusion must be agreed by both parties. The Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources previously raised the 2026 coal production target from around 600 million tons to around 720 million tons, but the quota increase does not automatically translate into certainty of export shipments because logistics bottlenecks and the pace of approvals still constrain actual shipments. Member of the National Energy Council (DEN), Kholid Syeirazi, warned that if regulatory uncertainty continues, "Indonesia risks losing export markets" because China has alternative options in Australia, Russia, and Mongolia.
For Chinese buyers, the logic of rejecting the waiver clause is also clear: power plant and industrial users need predictable supply continuity. If they accept the clause, Indonesian suppliers can legally reduce shipments when policies change, and buyers would be forced to fill the gap in the spot market at higher prices or bear the risk of depleting stocks. Bloomberg reported that contract delays and broad waiver clauses could expose Chinese buyers to spot price volatility and potentially divert demand to Australia and Mongolia.
As of press time, the stance of major Indonesian coal companies varies. PT Bukit Asam (PTBA) stated it has not encountered obstacles related to the waiver clause and existing export contracts are running normally; Indika Energy called contract adjustments a common practice in commodity trade that is always handled through open negotiation. But at the association level, APBI stated it "so far has not received reports from members on this matter."
The essence of this contract clause dispute is who bears the cost of Indonesian policy uncertainty. Indonesian exporters are seeking to shift the risk of government intervention to buyers through the waiver clause, while Chinese buyers respond with "not signing the contract," turning the pressure back on the Indonesian sellers. Ahead of the 2027 supply year, if the Indonesian government does not immediately clarify RKAB approvals and export rules, the loss of Indonesia's coal market share in China could turn from "risk" into "reality."
